Chapter 1: Intro
0:04Bread Tube, a loose and informal group of online content creators who create video content, including video essays and live streams from socialist, social
0:12democratic, communist, anarchist, and other left-wing perspectives. I've been covering some of the antics from Red Tube over the past year, and I think now
0:21is the perfect time I do one big video going over my issues with these people.
0:25Six issues to be exact. Starting with one, they're fake nice guys. A lot of these bread tubers build a persona revolving around them being wholesome and empathetic to those around them.
Chapter 2: Fake Nice Guys
0:35However, there are many times of the mass slips and their true colors come out. Many are just as hateful as the people they criticize. The only difference is that they are much less
0:44self-aware and act two-faced. This also makes them morally inconsistent, which will be a common theme throughout this video. The most widespread example of
0:51this is how these creators align themselves with the body positivity movement. Yet, at every opportune moment, they'll make fun of someone's physical attributes. And I think it's
0:59fine to make fun of a public figure's appearance. My problem is the hypocrisy.
1:03My favorite case of this is with Jake Doolittle, who's made numerous videos on this topic. He spends half of his Fat Spo video criticizing a 16-year-old girl
1:10with an eating disorder for saying mean things about fat people. He could have literally picked anybody else, but okay.
1:16He then made a video on Orange Peanut, a troll YouTuber who's made numerous videos goofing on fat acceptance Tik Tockers. This video from Jake ruffles
1:23some feathers. Because many of his criticism of Peanut is just him making fun of his appearance in a stutter.
1:28Like I understand that this guy is accepting of his, I don't know, armpit bruises. I agree. Maybe he could tell us how he's so confident in his small build. What's it like being 51?
1:40Um, yes they do. I've went through a bulk and a cut cycle when I was bulking.
1:44I got very big because I ate a lot. And when Why do you say yes they do like that? Yes, they don't. Yes, they do.
1:50Um, yes they do. I went through a bulk and a cut.
1:53You know, uh, making fun of my speech isn't very, uh, woke of you. It's not very politically correct. This is the exact same thing that Nick is not green
2:00did. He made fun of my stutter. I don't know why, but all these people who uh,
2:05preach like acceptance, political correctness, wokeness, they're all they do the same things at the end of the day. It's just they only do it when it
2:14benefits them and they know their audience is going to like it. Everybody is a piece of [ __ ] at the end of the day. It's just a matter of how. As Peanut just said, Nick is not green to
2:21do the same thing while also discussing body positivity and acceptance.
2:25I'm not forcing women to talk about anything. And as far as boobs go, we like boobs. We don't talk about them for 3 hours straight.
2:32Both of these guys get ratioed in the comments because they're more normal fans hate it when they do this crap.
2:37Though Jake turned off the comments and edited out part of the video that made him look bad, that being the weird consent comment. There's a possibility
2:44that you can't do certain things like bench an unconenting girl, right, Orange Peanut? Huh? You want to repeat that one for me,
2:52Jake? We went from nice, light-hearted roasts about appearances and background and content to all of a sudden you're accusing me of not caring about consent
3:01of girls. What the [ __ ] is wrong with you? No, genuinely.
3:06Again, there's that mask slip. Another prominent individual you'll see in this video is Ethan is online who does this [ __ ] all the time. He commonly mocks
3:14others appearances despite pushing against that. If I described to you a balding white man with a podcast who peaked in high school, you'd probably be
3:21able to perfectly capture exactly what this man looks like. Sorry to inject him into your head. Why does he look like that? Why are his eyes yellow like a
3:30Sith Lord? Why does he feel like he was built in Detroit become human? Who is this man? If he shaved everything but
3:37his mustache, he would look scary. He would look frightening. beard is giving Easter Island silhouette.
3:44Yeah, he does look like that. Someone point out he looks like a if from his profile he looks like a crescent moon. Yeah, when his appearance is criticized, he throws a hissy fit.
3:52I don't like I'm a little overweight. I don't like how it feels. Still do something about it.
3:57I am, [ __ ] It's really frustrating that your [ __ ] audience keeps commenting that [ __ ] when I do.
4:03I used to be heavier, [ __ ] But it's, you know, you don't [ __ ] change overnight. Call me Ethan. Now you're the one getting mad.
4:10You literally were just like, "Do something about it. [ __ ] off, [ __ ]
4:15It's mean. You're mean. When you talk about weight [ __ ] you're mean and I don't like it." By the way, this dude flat out lied. He looked like this when
4:23he started YouTube. Noah Samson is another bread tuber I've covered before who's also made fun of people's appearances and mannerisms. But there are even bigger examples of this dude
4:31being two-faced. He definitely portrays himself as a calm, understanding individual just to get up for disenfranchised groups. But this moral high ground he stands on is just for
4:40show. On Twitter, he's made multiple death threats. Though if asked, he'll just explain it as jokes like they always do. First is after he lost a
4:47debate to Vosch with him liking a tweet where someone wanted Vosch to be put down like a dog. Then during the Super Mega drama, Noah wanted Chud Logic to be melted into a large cast iron cauldron.
4:57And by the way, the pedophile part is borderline slander. Even Keeffles and Xanderhal who both hate Chudlo Logic don't think Chud is a pedto.
5:05Chudlo Logic and all. He is not a pedophile though. I am very familiar with the drama that happened where people tried to slander him as a pedto.
5:12I even spoke to him in private about that drama when it was going down and got like the the all the screenshots and info and everything. He's not a pedto.
5:22Here's where I'll make a correction from the last time I talked about Noah. I stated that this tweet was what got him banned from Twitter, but what really got him banned was this tweet describing how
5:30he killed Elon Musk. This is the same guy making videos of this crappy bisexual lighting, ironically wearing made outfits. By the way, these guys
5:37don't fool me. They're fake nice guys who take advantage of their viewers.
5:40Leading us to our next point, two, they weaponize their audience. I've seen many instances of bread tubers using their audience as either a sword or a shield.
Chapter 3: Weaponize Their Audiences
5:49For instance, they'll use them as a suitable defense against opposition or to attack and harass those they deem irredeemable. My favorite example of the
5:56former is definitely the Balenciaga scandal, which I went over more in detail in my denims video. Basically,
6:02this fashion company posted some sus marketing photos. One showcasing a document relating to a CP court case and other showing little girls holding teddy
6:10bears that have bondage on. YouTuber Shuan Head was pretty much the figurehead of this controversy, calling out Balenciaga's actions and giving updates. bread tubers that she deemed friends being Xander Hall, Demon Mama,
6:21and Denims, called her out for this with very bizarre reasonings. They all tried downplaying the controversy while at the same time insisting it would negatively
6:28affect the LGBTQ community. This had nothing to do with queer people. Yet,
6:32they for some reason insisted that this will give conservatives fodder to spread hate. Later realized that they were the ones giving them fodder by even implying gay people have something to do with
6:40this. So Xanderhal says Shuon head on her way to once again use her massive platform to provide the neo-Nazis and her audience with fodder they can use to
6:49justify the murder of gay people. But this time one day after an anti-gay terror attack. By the way, [ __ ] based Xanderhal. Can we get some [ __ ]
6:59hypers in chat for Xanderhal having the balls and the spine and the gigachad energy to be a real trans ally? Because unironically, that's what it looks like.
7:11Xanderhal out here [ __ ] spitting and showing you all how it's done. Calm down, dog. It's just a shitty Patrick Baitman meme. Basically, these people
7:20are waiting for a good opportunity to [ __ ] on chew on head as they don't like the fact that she goes after both sides in videos. They use their audiences,
7:26which are filled with lots of queer people, to attack someone else by manipulating them into thinking the scandal will negatively affect them in any way. Vox would use a similar tactic
7:34earlier this year when his special folder got leaked live on stream. You can see this is an example of the kind of structure that I'm referring to. If
7:41you somehow don't know what he had on there, it was AI generated images involving horses and little girls doing some pretty disgusting things. When
7:49Ethan Klein and other YouTubers called him out for being a lolly enjoyer, he clapped back with this.
7:54I like the part where he said this is a pedophile community. Um, yeah. Did did did he uh did he say that with regards
8:01to there being a lot of transgenders here? Is that what he meant? Curious.
8:05It's not a pedo community because trans people are part of it. It's because parts of your audience are defending the fact that you're sexually attracted to kids and have made numerous arguments
8:12for why CP should be legal. So, you know, there's pedophiles, right, who buy child pornography. Would you say they
8:19should not be held responsible for doing that? Yes.
8:23Really? Even though they're directly supporting child rape? Yeah, I think that's it's uh it's hypocritical. If if I I cuz I bought my computer and the
8:32silicon in it was farmed in Africa by slaves. If I can do that and that's legal and no one's going to call me out in my [ __ ] then yeah, I have to be consistent in that respect.
8:42Nice false equivalency there, douchebag.
8:44The difference is that one product could be made ethically while the other cannot. Vosch can make the excuse that he's debaterained all he wants, but that folder and the loads of other evidence
8:52that he's into proves that wrong. It's just gross how he automatically thinks an attack on his defenders is an overall attack on trans people. One of those
9:00defenders was Keeles, who in my opinion is way worse than Vosch. It would take too long to cover all the awful things she's done. So, I'll summarize it as
9:08this. She kept changing the story about her doxing, lied about which website doxed her for more clout, raised $100,000 for a supposed legal case, and
9:15then wasted the money on vacation and streaming gear, knew about the grooming that went on in her Discord server,
9:20admitted to grooming minors, and promoted a site that sells homemade drugs to minor that has a lolly on the packaging. When Mudahar released this video showcasing the evidence for all of
9:29this, Keville used the ultimate trump card, transphobia, she spread this lie to her audience, stating that Muda used the wrong pronouns in the announcement
9:36tweet and that the art in the thumbnail was transphobic. These claims are [ __ ] as all hell, but Kuffles die hard fans believed it and started going
9:43after Muda. They even made up conspiracy theories for how his wife is some sort of fascist right-winger. Late last year,
9:50Jake Dittle released a hit piece of sorts on Ethan Klein, basically accusing him of faking a health scare for money.
9:55In reality, Ethan did legit think he had lupus and was very open about it on stream. Jake did this under the guise of defending those in his audience would
10:02have chronic illnesses like himself. If he made things personal like that, he knew his audience would be more willing to go after Ethan and ruin his career in some way. This didn't end up happening,
10:11which I'll bring up later. But basically, Jake was once again using his Lime disease to benefit himself financially. He also has a nonprofit that sells branded merch. What the
10:20website doesn't tell you is that 90% of the profits from his overpriced junk goes to him. Only 10% goes to people in need. Jake had only admitted to this at
10:28the end of a few videos. Also, if you feel like it, you can donate to the Never Stop Fund. 10% of all profits from the clothing brand go into the fund. So,
10:36either way, you're helping people out. If you're selling merch on a nonprofit,
10:39you probably shouldn't be taking profits from it. Kind of scummy, dude. It's more clear now on the website, but still.
10:45Sorry about that tangent. Anyways, I want to give one more example of these guys weaponizing their audiences with malicious intent. The super mega drama.
10:52I won't get too detailed into this because there's loads of other videos that do a good job at that, but basically a bunch of YouTubers and streamers made statements accusing Matt
11:00Watson and Ryan McGee of some pretty awful things. Most of these statements were disproven involving cheating and homophobia, but what stuck around a bit
11:07longer was the allegations spread by Lex Updog. She alleges that Matt and Ryan knowingly covered up her sexual assault by a channel artist. Yet, they showed evidence of her wanting to keep it
11:16private. Many of her other claims are also disproven, but Lex, her pal Nick is not green and her boyfriend Ethan is online stayed stubborn throughout this
11:24drama. They pretty much used the topic of essay to motivate their audience to cancel Super Mega, even holding a live stream on Ethan's second channel to celebrate. This was pretty gross
11:32behavior, especially when Matt and Ryan's late friend Daniel was brought up. Lex alleged that the two would make jokes about his passing, which they denied. Even if they did, who cares?
11:41They're allowed to make jokes about their trauma. I mean, Ryan was the one who found his body. The person making these claims never knew Daniel. They
11:49definitely were not a part of the group that experienced the trauma of losing him. And I think honestly it is
11:57disrespectful to bring him up as a weapon. I felt like he was just brought into the situation for drama's sake to
12:06try to hurt me or Matt or hurt our image. I have done enough [ __ ] to
12:14tarnish my image, but I will not stand by and let someone talk lies about the
12:21way I talked or treated my trauma in regards to Daniel. Though fans of the trio didn't care and left various nasty
12:30comments on his goodbye video, so much so that the comments had to be turned off. Only Nick would apologize for this and Ethan and Lex would remain adamant
12:37that all their allegations are true. For someone who holds people super responsible for what they say, you truly are a hypocrite, Ethan. And as a creator, spreading this kind of
12:46parasocial rhetoric um and allowing it to be okay on your channel is not only irresponsible, but it's probably going to bite you in the ass one day. But this
12:54isn't the only tactic these guys use to attack their opponents. They also love labeling them as full-blown extremists. Three, they dehumanize their opponents.
Chapter 4: Dehumanize Their Opponents
13:02Bread Tube, being filled with many on the far left, view those of opposing viewpoints as inherently bad. Even those who most wouldn't consider right-wing,
13:10even the occasional leftwing personalities get called Nazis from time to time. They do this due to two to an either with us or against this mentality, trying to draw a line between
13:18their side and everyone else. This instead alienates people and makes them more radical, which is not a good thing on either side of the political spectrum. I first brought this topic up
13:26in my Noah Samson video as he loves to label his opponents as incelss, red pillars, reactionaries, or fascists. An issue I have with this is that he
13:35doesn't properly define these terms as he kind of throws them around all willy-nilly. I mean, there's this one video where he shows a cringy workout motivation video and describes it as
13:44this. Like, I'm all for a little gym motivation, right? But why does it have to be a little bit fascist, you know? I don't know. Seems not great.
13:51What does showing fat people as lazy have to do with fascism? You can criticize that video without making it so political like that. Another bread tuber who unnecessarily used the term
13:59fascist is Big Joel, who made a video titled Conservative Comedy Destroyed My Life. In this video, he reviews the Nostalgia Critic video on the 1982 Pink
14:08Floyd film, The Wall. It's a pretty bad video, and I went over why in my worst YouTuber song List, but Joel's criticism of it is incredibly questionable. I
14:16mean, Doug himself is not political, and neither is this video really. Joel alludes to Doug being a liberal centrist, but then calls him reactionary as he dives into a contentious scene.
14:25The scene being parodyied alludes to fascism, while the parody itself has a pretty pretentious message about cancel culture. But it wasn't intended to spread any sort of political messaging.
14:34This doesn't stop Joel from saying this.
14:37Doug looks at a film about a Nazi who screams about murdering Jews and says,
14:42"That guy is just like me. I'm going to make a whole song about how much I love that guy." And that's not funny. At least not on purpose. It's sad. Again,
14:51criticize this shitty video all you want, but you lost me when he tried to string together a political message out of it. Other Brettubers use similar tactics to create sort of a scapegoat
15:00for the opposition, in order to discuss a criticism. During the Super Mega Drama, Nick would refer to his haters as Reddit debate dorks. The first time was indirectly in a separate video. Today,
15:10I'm wearing my scary shirt to make me look a lot a lot more scary.
15:15Ah, there's too many Reddit debate bro dorks on this website trying to come after me every single day. So, I thought
15:23I'd show him a little bit of what I'm made of, you know? Do I look scary?
15:26Sure, buddy. Anyways, he says something similar in an Instagram story, very clearly referencing Destiny, who began looking into the Super Mega drama thanks
15:34to Turkey Tom. Then, we come to In Praise of Shadows, who I'll call Zayn for the rest of the video. surprised I really haven't discussed or talked about
15:42him on the channel yet, though to be fair, a lot of channels did. I did archive the original video, so you're welcome. Basically, this dude makes
15:49horror movie videos and made a really bad review of The Hills Have Eyes, where he compares the cannibals to American Minorities. This basically sent him into
15:57a downward spiral, leading to the video bad conservative horror movies. Most of this video has nothing to do with the title and is mainly a response to the
16:05hate he gets, along with being a hit piece against a bunch of YouTubers. He is a hate owner for the main one being Wendigon who he describes as a fascist
16:12bootlicker claiming to be very against the government and for the rights of the people while at the same time giving a warm embrace to one of the biggest fascist bootlickers on the internet. And
16:21the only thing that one could reasonably gather from this picture of them hugging is that he too is a fascist bootlicker himself. Dude, donut operator is a
16:29former cop who occasionally criticizes other cops. What are you on about? A lot of this segment is just Zayn trying to label all of Wendigon's friends as
16:36right-wing fascists. Despite most of them not being political at all, they just like guns and wond himself as Christian. One of the only political
16:44YouTubers he mentions is Shu, who Zayn refers to as this. He is publicly friends with Shu on head, who is a conservative masquerading as a leftist,
16:52who has built a career off of lazy anti-woke content complaining about SJWs, who says stuff like Karl Marx rising from the grave, finding out his movement has been taken over by fat,
17:03ugly, mentally ill losers. Yeah, she was on a secret conservative.
17:07She voted for Bernie Sanders. Lumping these pretty average people as right-wing extremists is pretty hilarious as this dude is an actual extremist. I mean, at one point he
17:15claims that Wendyon should be allowed in public due to the beliefs Zayn described him. I care deeply about horror and everything that he does has demonstrated
17:23so far in his career that he should not be welcomed in our spaces or even, you know, just in public in general.
17:30He also accuses Wendigo of being racist strictly because of the area he lives in. Deep Appalachia is very white country and for the most part is
17:38exceptionally racist. Genuinely in this part of the country, you have to assume that any white person you meet is racist unless they show you otherwise. Hm. Why
17:47would I call someone who judges another person based on skin color? Oh, I know.
17:51Racism. Good job, Zayn. Glad people like you determining who's racist. Now, I really didn't see any other red tubers offending this dude as this video is bad
17:59even for their standards. Though, these guys produce similarly bad faith videos.
18:03It's just never this blatant. Noah Samson recently talked about Zayn mentioning that was just weird.
18:08So, in case you couldn't tell by the footage he's showing on the screen, this guy's referencing it seems like In Praise of Shadows video about Wendy Goon, if anyone is familiar with that.
18:16My audience might not be, but uh pretty weird video. Pretty weird and bad video.
18:20I like that guy's videos otherwise. That was just a really weird video. I guarantee you no one is downplaying it because his exposed videos are just as poorly done. I mean, his a Cheeto video
18:28basically painted him as a terrorist for reacting to something from Libs at Tik Tok. He also accused Patient Zena of creating a right-wing pipeline for not thinking racism wasn't the only reason
18:36people didn't like the Little Mermaid remake and has made numerous attempts at Duncan on Think Before You Sleep for being far right and doing bad research.
18:44These usually never worked for him and he even deleted the patient Zeno video earlier this year. They do this because at the end of the day, Breubers are only really looking to make their political
18:52team look good, not having nuanced or interesting discussions, which leads us to our next point. Four, they treat everything as team sports. A lot of the
Chapter 5: Team Sports
19:00hypocrisies in this community come down to them only caring about what those on the right or censor do. If someone on their side of the aisle does something bad or questionable, they either look
19:08the other way or try to downplay it. The most recent example of this is with the Ava Chris Tyson situation with only a few bread tubers covering it. If you
19:16somehow don't know, Ava has been accused of grooming multiple miners on Discord and buying lolly art among other things.
19:23While covering it on stream, Ethan is online decided to downplay it all by saying Ava was just posting some edgy tweets seven years ago and that people
19:31change. He gets pressed for seemingly defending Ava and having some level of bias. I will say that I do have a bi I have a recency bias. I have a bias for
19:40[ __ ] that has actually happened in the last five [ __ ] years. I mean, Jesus,
19:48they chose a bias.
19:52I can say that what Chris was doing on the internet in 2017 is [ __ ] gross.
19:56Unacceptable, but she doesn't do that anymore. She doesn't do that. It's not acceptable. I agree with you. Okay,
20:03first off, bro, this [ __ ] is beyond gross. And second, these tweets go up to 2019, 5 years ago. Your recency bias
20:10should apply. God, he looks like a courage dog villain. Also, Ethan doesn't clearly think that way because his most popular second channel video is over 30
20:18minutes of him criticizing creepy things Matt Walsh said a decade ago and he even complains about hypocrisy here. I think you should absolutely give people the
20:27benefit of the doubt that they have changed when you see them have an old take that's a bad take. But when you dig
20:34up something from 15 years ago on Matt Walsh and it's still perfectly in line with his worldview and there's no
20:41evidence that he's ever changed and he still thinks that way and you can reasonably assume that he still thinks
20:49that way and he's publicly saying these kinds of things. It doesn't matter how old it is. He might as well have said that [ __ ] clip yesterday because he's the same stupid incel pedophile [ __ ]
21:02This is despite the fact that Ethan criticized Alex Rosen for his old pedal hunting tactics, which the guys improved upon. In Ethan's video on Alex, he
21:10points out many times that Alex is conservative and tries to paint him as a creepy [ __ ] Though at the same time, he makes weird statements like that Alex
21:18was harassing EDP, seemingly sympathizing with Apedo. And so he and his weird little cameraman are just harassing EDP and asking him a bunch of
21:26really stupid questions like, "Why do you do this, man?" Later, he criticizes Alex for not helping self- admitted pedos. Like, this dude probably makes
21:34plenty of money off this [ __ ] but he's not paying for therapy. He's not getting these guys into like a housing that's away from like anyone they could do any
21:41harm to that has no internet. He's not doing [ __ ] And he gets called a hero for it by hogs like Michael Nolles. Yeah, the housing is called prison.
21:50which is where Alex is sending these creepy [ __ ] to since he works with law enforcement. Now, the fact that this dude is willing to go up to bat to defend literal predators just to dunk on
21:58some conservative is really bizarre to me, man. He could have just not mentioned any of the predator stuff and focus on the guy's beliefs, but no.
22:05Is it just cuz they're idiots? Are they idiots? Yeah, I'd say a lot of them are. But,
22:13you know, I Okay, Michael Nolles is a [ __ ] idiot.
22:16What kind of question is that? Are pedophiles pedophiles? are stupid.
22:20This is the same guy who made a video trying to disprove the gay groomer narrative and then twisted it by saying Catholic conservatives are the real pedto with his only example being a
22:2850-year-old case of a gay priest molesting a boy. It is pretty extensively documented how much of a pedophile defender uh Archbishop John
22:37Roach was. He literally had the sexual assaulter of multiple boys. Multiple boys.
22:42Good job, Ethan. Defending gay people by listing off one of them as an example.
22:46Another bread tuber who's been downplaying the Ava situation is Denims,
22:50and I eventually plan to talk about her takes on this in a future video.
22:54Basically, she spends two hours slowly reviewing the drama and cherrypicking the lousiest evidence to show to her audience. She claims she doesn't think
23:01the art on Ava's wall was loy and dismisses other tweets she made as edgy nonsense. When called out on her hypocrisy, she reacts with hostility.
23:10Oh, you guys are so you guys are so cute.
23:14One day after the former Twitch staff tweet about Doc, but now your nar Why did we ban him? I was responding. But now your narrative changes when the Pedo
23:21is trans. Did Did you I think it's cute that you want to believe that we're not consistent. But we are. It's you guys that aren't consistent.
23:31I think buying a poster from this weird pedonazi artist is [ __ ] creepy and strange.
23:37[Music]
23:39I also think a 33-year-old man trying to meet up with a minor is creepy and insane,
23:46but it's cute that you want to believe that we're not consistent on our positions.
23:50She's referring to the doctor disrespect situation, which many compared this to for obvious reasons. Denims doesn't think this is as bad despite there being
23:57way more evidence against Ava. When the doc made his statements, Denims was quick to make multiple tweets calling him out. Yet, with Ava, she's pretty
24:05silent and is quick to question the accusers. This is another instance where I feel like it's very bizarre that people are comparing the Dr. Disrespect situation to Ava's situation because Dr.
24:14Disrespect was a 33-year-old man flirting with minors. Ava was a 20-year-old trying to make stupid jokes with minors. One of them is like, "Dude,
24:24what the [ __ ] are you thinking? You're crazy. This is a you're trying to commit a felony." And the other one is like,
24:29"Oh my god, you are cringe. You are beyond cringe." Casey Tron, Denim's friend, has also been downplaying this
24:37despite how aggressive she's been with the doc. This hypocrisy extends to those on the opposing side with Sneo and Nick Merks downplaying what the doc did.
24:45Though one side is more blatant about it. Denims has flat out admitted before that she doesn't think covering drama from her neck of the woods is worth her time, saying this in the same stream
24:53where she defends Keles's. My perspective is I don't like to spend my time um
25:01going after other people that are on the left, right? And that's just because I think my time is better spent
25:08making fun of people on the right. You guys can disagree. And I'm not saying that no one should ever do this. And I'm not saying that I think it's bad to do
25:16this. I'm saying I don't like to spend my time fighting with people who are saying that they're on the left. The fact she'll openly say this just shows
25:23how brainwashed our audience is. Noah Samson is also guilty of this as he'd go out of his way to accuse Think Before You Sleep of leading to Illmation's
25:31doxing. Yet only a month prior he was called out for being publicly friends of a known doxer. This is bad empanada another tuber who just like Noah hates
25:40Vos and Xanderhal. Emp invited Noah to be part of his charity stream. With Noah making a now deleted community post,
25:46he'd get some flack for this and not attend with Emp mentioning this on the stream. Someone chat ask you about uh I haven't seen him ask about Noah. What about Noah Samson?
25:55Uh Noah said that he can't come on. I'm not sure if he can't come on because he got like yelled at by pedophile fans or because he just actually can't come on,
26:03but it's one of those things. Damn.
26:05The real reason is because he got called out by other leftists for supporting a known doxer who sends targeted harassment campaigns against his critics. This guy also has a history
26:13making pro 911 statements and is allegedly a creep. One of the guys he docks was someone he was trying to sue for alleging that he was a pedophile,
26:21which there is evidence for, though it's nothing super concrete. But yeah, Noah has never made a public statement regarding Epanata, though he left up a
26:29community post regarding unrelated criticism. These two are still following each other on Instagram. So, this tells me that Noah doesn't give a [ __ ] about
26:36harassment or doxing as long as someone he likes does it. I mean, here's him initiating a targeted harassment campaign against Xanderhal.
26:43Stop it. He'll probably complain about being clipped out of context, but I mean, the full video is there. It's It's a full video. You You can watch the whole thing. Also, if you do go there,
26:51don't say anything mean, please. Just comment Squid Gang with six G's. Yet, he gives TBYS [ __ ] for doing the exact opposite and discouraging his audience
26:59from leaving mean comments on Ilia's video. Noah also ignored the fact that on multiple occasions, Illy sends her fans to mass report TBys's video despite
27:07it being pretty tame and not being considered cyber bullying under YouTube's strict rules. He even downplays it by saying TVYS is just a crybaby for even considering this could
27:16lead to deplatforming. Oh, and speaking of cryb babies five, the crybullies.
Chapter 6: Crybullies
27:21Many of these creators make content poking fun at and criticizing others they dislike. Though, what I've noticed is that when these guys get backlash themselves, they plead innocence and act
27:29the victim. This is so common that I literally have loads of examples. The first one I'll bring up being from Noah,
27:35who made a hippie on Vosch and then debated him. Noah came across as spineless and couldn't properly debate against any of Vos's points and then took the video down. He then put the
27:44video back up once the hate died down and made another. Ever since then, he's declined to do another debate, still mulling over how badly Vos whooped his
27:52ass. Jeez, imagine losing a debate to so many jerks off to images of little girls. Now with Jake Dittle, he'd get loads of backlash on his H3 video,
28:01making an Instagram story after Ethan teas a new podcast episode. He'd use death threats to debate sympathy, as if every big YouTuber doesn't get them.
28:09Ethan was actually debating not covering Jake's video, but Jake still kept the video up until an hour into the podcast.
28:15Oh. Oh, he just privated it. Well, it's too late, bro. No, it's too late. It's too late, Jake.
28:23Oops.
28:24You had all three [ __ ] weeks to do it, man. He's watching, I'm assuming.
28:30Yeah, probably. Jake, you had three weeks and every comment on the video was like, "This is a bad take. Social media,
28:38this is a bad take." Nobody liked,
28:41nobody was down with it. And it took him until now, for some reason, when I'm here actually defending myself. Like,
28:48bro, you have a public video up with like 125,000 views, and people that aren't familiar with me and my show can
28:55take away a really nasty impression of me. So, of course, I'm I have every single right to come here and respond.
29:01And the fact that you just took it down now is not going to save you, brother. You might as well just bring it back up.
29:09Public [ __ ]
29:10I recommend you watch this segment. It's 3 hours of Ethan satisfyingly destroying Jake. It took Jake over a week to make an apology where he gives no context and
29:19says a bunch of cliche gobbledegook. My intention was to stand up for a specific group of people, but instead I came
29:26across as an [ __ ] I didn't consider how my words would affect others, and for that, I'm very sorry. I've also come to realize that no amount of explanation
29:35can undo the impact of that video, and so for the discomfort or hurt that it caused, I also apologize. He take his
29:42original down, though I managed to archive it on my second channel. He then placed a copyright takedown request, which he did have the right to do.
29:50Though, it's obvious he did this because he wanted the drama that he started to go away when he took his apology video down a month ago, the same thing
29:57happened. Though, when he placed the takedown request, I noticed that he put it back up. Yes, this guy was going to quietly take it down. Though, when I
30:05caught it, he decided to undo that. What a coward, man. These guys always make the lousiest apologies where they try to take responsibility for as little as possible until that gets them more hate.
30:15This happened with Zayn, who made various tweets only apologizing for the most egregious points he made, like when he spread false rape threat claims made
30:23by Sneo towards Brandon Buckingham. He is friends with Brandon Buckingham, a gun YouTuber who has been accused of threatening rape, though he sucked by
30:30many of the other claims made, like that Mudahar is transphobic for the Keell thumbnail. Zay then rant on Discord about the hate, effectively getting off
30:38social media after deleting the video. I find this funny because he was talking about how he was low on money since his videos barely get views anymore and he
30:45hasn't uploaded in 3 months. Then we get to Nick who should get the world record for making the most apologies to a single case of drama. There's at least
30:52five I can think of with the most concrete being the one he uploaded in January. He finally fully admits to [ __ ] up in regards to the super mega
31:00drama and shows regret towards the other mean-spirited videos he's made.
31:03Remember, this guy spent months avoiding responsibility and only made this as a last ditch effort to regain some of his audience. After Nick's most recent
31:11apology, which he made on his third channel, Ethan would go live on Twitch and get asked about it. He gets immediately angry and basically pushes
31:19all the blame regarding the Super Mega controversy to Nick. People were praising him for the vid. Yeah, annoying commentary watchers and liars
31:28were saying, "This is such a good video because you apologized to the guys that I like and apologized for,
31:35you know, hurting their feelings." I guess he literally apologized for playing the gift of [ __ ] Matt Watson getting
31:44punched in the face. You're really apologizing for that? He's a rape apologist.
31:55Play it 10 times, 100 times.
31:58I can't be friends with people who are that like easy to fold. I can't trust people like that. Ethan,
32:06that's you. Dude, remember the Alex Rosen video when you got [ __ ] for that?
32:10You made a Twitter thread basically victimizing herself and whining about people jokingly calling you a pedo. Yet,
32:15you have a history of loosely calling others pedos. They they think that I'm mature enough to have a 9-year-old daughter and be a pedophile, too, cuz you look like a pedophile.
32:23So, Ethan is just as spineless as Nick,
32:25but he has more of a fake tough guy persona. As seen anytime he DMs a creator he doesn't like. About a week after that Nick stream, Ethan would go
32:33live again with Lex this time where they'd basically get raided by lyrics. I was watching this live and had a bit of fun trolling them myself. You and Vos date. What?
32:44Why would you say that? He's a pedophile.
32:52They basically get riled up in every little joke someone makes. Acting as if they have the moral high ground while not realizing everyone is wasting their time.
32:58Still think you should watch the big bungee video on you would wipe the slate clean with this chat. That video has [ __ ] revenge porn in it. It is a
33:07deranged like [ __ ] delusion made by a 4chan basement dweller. I'm not watching that.
33:17You're sick in the head if you think there's [ __ ] good critiques in it.
33:20And if you want to [ __ ] make the points, repeat them. Regurgitate like you do all these dumbass questions.
33:31Based Bungeie, my favorite YouTuber, Baisy Bungeie.
33:37It's so funny to see you see. Dude, you haven't made a single point. I hope you're proud of yourself, but you haven't. Yes, that's Lexa's real laugh.
33:46She got that Kamla Harris hyena screech. Oh my god, you're so stupid.
33:53Is it? Wait, I'm I'm You are so stupid. Average intelligence of my [ __ ] haters, dude. Right [ __ ] here.
34:02All these losers in chat need to go get a [ __ ] job. Oh, it was the wrong word.
34:07Where are some lame ass limp blurp [ __ ] instead of making a proper video debunking the hate he gets.
34:13He'd rather spend hours of his time debating random [ __ ] He'd end up privating this VOD, but archives do exist. Now, lastly, I want to briefly
34:21cover Vos's defenders slowly leaving the internet, or at least trying to. You got Keeles, who deleted her last few YouTube videos and has been silently streaming
34:29since May. Then, she pretty much decided to leave the internet after messages leaked of Xanderhal threatening to beat her and her orbiters to death. all because they have small personal
34:37disagreements and the fact that Keeles was friendly with Suan Head in the past.
34:41It was also revealed that Xander Hollow view used his editor and didn't pay them. Sticking by Keles even after the Muda video was tipster, a former
34:49commentary streamer who's married yet likes to hit on other women. He not only defended Keles, but also defended Vos's lolly obsession. He ended up removing
34:57all the videos on his channel after the backlash, but then put back up the videos he made after lining himself with Bread Tube. Finally, we get to Jaylen,
35:04someone I've surprisingly never talked about on this channel. She's extensively a low cow known for constantly getting themselves into drama, apologizing for it, threatening to leave the internet,
35:13and then coming back after a day. This has become known as the Jaylen cycle.
35:17Usually starting with them picking beef on a commentary channel or calling a black guy the gamer word,
35:22no one else should care. I find it just really funny that they like they say on Twitter, "Yeah, all transphobic people are pedophiles and just being openly transphobic towards Ringo."
35:33That's not being transphobic. I can make 41% jokes. Also, Ringo's literally Ringo's also literally making the same jokes. Like, what the [ __ ] you talking
35:41about, [ __ ] Like, what the [ __ ] Are you [ __ ]
35:46You're not black. You're not You're not black, Jaylen. You're not allowed to say you're not allowed to say that word. Are you racist? I am black. Jesus all hypocrites.
35:55Yet Jallen will have a problem with people making trans jokes. She recently defended Vosch and Keffles, though the straw that finally broke the camel's back was her downplaying the Ava Tyson
36:03situation, which finally got her to leave the internet and rename her channel to Inactive. Many Brett tubers rely on flimsy arguments that can easily
36:11be debunked. And when they do get debunked, they throw a hissy fit about it and act innocent. If you're going to [ __ ] talk on the internet, be ready for others to [ __ ] talk you. But many of
36:20these guys have no backbone and can't even take jokes. And that leads to my last point. Six, they're safe, edgy.
Chapter 7: Safe Edgy
36:26This is definitely the least important point, but it's something I've been wanting to talk about. I've noticed that many bread tubers are safe edgy. As Zen,
36:34they target their jokes and quips at certain people, yet would get backlash from their audience if they did it to others. This term began after a trend was noticed. The influx of memes poking fun of British and French people. Yet,
36:44if you make jokes like this towards other people, especially those in non-white countries, you'll get [ __ ] on by bread tubers who will try to label you as problematic or something. Many of
36:52these guys don't even know what safe edgy is. That being said, certain personalities do gravitate towards certain styles, like this safe, sleazy kind of thing. First, we had safe edgy,
37:04then safe horny, and now safe sleazy to finish the trifecta.
37:08Why does he put a map of Europe for safe edgy? What does that mean? Wait, is that even Europe or is it Why is there a big gap there? Is this like pangia or something? Am I tripping? What does this
37:16mean? Okay, looks like Germany's missing and then some other stuff. Um, France.
37:21So, is that like the countries they invaded? Well, no. Germany invaded Poland and it's still there. Look,
37:25someone someone help. This part of the video should help you, Noah. Safe edgy is basically comedy that appears risque.
37:31Yeah, would never actually get you into trouble for saying it. As said in the section about fake nice guys, these bread tubers only make fun of the appearances of straight men or those who
37:39politically disagree with them. But let's say if they were to make fun of a trans person's appearance, they get eaten alive by their own audience. They
37:46basically trap themselves into a box they can't escape. He's not a bread tuber, per se, but this sort of thing happened of Ethan Klein a few years ago.
37:54On the rare occasion he said something actually edgy, he'd get crucified for it. I mean, Jake Dittle was part of that audience. He got offended over some jokes Ethan made about chronic
38:02illnesses. Few things leading up to this video. I was a huge fan of the H3 podcast when I was at my sickest. So leading up to this, he was a huge fan,
38:11right?
38:12The minute I brushed AC across something he cares about a little bit, brushed upon it. Now he's he's done. All bets are off.
38:20I'm exposing him too far. Something that I really want to talk about with this topic is that safe edgginess can exist on both sides of the political extremes. I mean, one side
38:28normalizes jokes about religion, white people, masculinity, while the other side normalizes jokes about racial and sexual identity. The opposing side will get offended by the other's jokes. Yeah,
38:38we'll make equally edgy material relating to what they deem socially acceptable. I think you should make jokes about any of this as long as that's a joke. You can't be talking
38:46about why America deserves 9/11 unironically and present that as a joke because there's no punchline.
38:51America deserve 9/11. I can't disavow facts, man. I can't disavow reality. That's not how that works, bro. Like,
38:59even ironically, it's not funny because there's nothing else to the joke. That's why Shane Dawson's old comedy isn't funny. There's nothing to the joke besides doing something edgy. Even
39:07ignoring the safe edgy problem, I still wouldn't find these guys funny. Much of their humor comes from them being snarky or passive aggressive, which only works
39:14if you're likable. If you've been paying attention to this video, you'll notice that these guys are the opposite of likable. They seem pretentious and all-
39:22knowing, never being able to make fun of themselves and have self-awareness. I mean, at the slightest joke at their expense, they get furious. I mean,
39:29here's Nick making multiple different tweets, raging over the most tame Tik Tok comment in existence. Though, there is one Brtuber I do find funny. Ryan Beard.
Chapter 8: Conclusion
39:40I mentioned Ryan Beard at the end there because for the past eight months, I've noticed this fair criticism of many of the other bird tubers in this video. Now, I'm not a big fan of Ryan. In fact,
39:49I disagree with a few of his takes.
39:51Though, at the end of the day, that's bound to happen. Not everyone is going to have the same thought process as you.
39:56What really matters is your ability to argue for what you stand for. I appreciate Ryan now because he's the only bread tuber I've seen actively call out the rash and improper behavior of his peers. in pretty respectable ways.
40:06Mind you, I first noticed this with Jake Dittle's H3 hit piece as Ryan left a constructive comment explaining why the video was bad. Jake being a pouty child deleted this comment and many others.
40:17Ryan would also call out Noah Samson for working a bad empanada, seeing him as a bad look. Then he'd criticize Keels for trying to accuse Muda of being
40:25transphobic. When Gokinaru was discussing Zayn's Wendigon video, Ryan would show up in chat and rightfully criticize the guy, strangely agreeing
40:32with a Cheeto, which I thought could never happen. See, this is why this is See, this is the goated nature of a Gokanara stream. We can have Ryan Beard
40:40and a Cheeto in the same [ __ ] stream chat. Do you understand how how universal this this little experience is? It's like a cultural exchange, bro.
40:50During Ethan's live stream meltdown, Ryan would chat on lyrics of stream. Yo,
40:56what is Dude, what is this alliance? Is this Mr. Beard? Dude, it's Ryan Beard.
41:03Ethan needs to log off. He's clearly spiraling, but doesn't What happened? Wait,
41:09wait, did something happen to Ryan? Is this the real Ryan Beard?
41:13What happened to Ryan Beard since the last time I've seen him? Ethan needs to log off. He's clearly spiraling, but doesn't realize it. Him and Lex suck,
41:20though, so whatever. Somebody hack his accounts or have I just completely been out of the loop on Mr. Beard? Uh, or
41:28yeah, Mr. Beard. Ryan Beard. Uh, him and Lex suck though. Whatever. What happened? I thought this guy was completely on like the super mega train.
41:35Maybe I Maybe I just completely haven't been familiar with him. But this is an a Dude, this is an awesome chat message
41:43right here. Completely spiraling. I thought he was friends with this guy.
41:47Dude, shout out to Ryan Beard W. Him and Lex suck, dude. Let's [ __ ] go. I'm not friends with Ethan anymore after he
41:54justified anti-semitism and told me I was victim blaming when I got mad at Lex for lying about Nick is not green. Let's
42:01[ __ ] go. Dude, Ryan Beard is [ __ ]
42:04[ __ ] spitting flames in the chat right now. Um, I'm still just as much of a leftist, but Ethan makes other leftists look like freaks when he
42:12releases terrible videos like the Alex Rosen one, so I have no desire to associate with them. Dude, based Ryan Beard. Hey man, I'll see you later, Ryan
42:20Beard. Uh, don't worry though, if Ethan calls you a pedo, that just means that he wants you to get free therapy. Lol.
42:25All right, I need to stop. See you guys later. Have a good one, man. This is why I'm starting to like Ryan. Even if you disagree with something he said, this
42:33guy has, you know, morals. He has morals that he stands by and can actually interact positively with those who differ from him. In other words, he's actually a mature adult. And honestly,
42:43not all bread tubers are bad. Some of the others I failed to mention are just people I disagree with. You can criticize them for that, but they're not awful people. But like Ryan said, there
42:52are those like Ethan or couples that make them look bad, and the others on the side of the internet do a bad job at weeding them out. A lot of them are quiet on these topics, which only lets his madness continue for years to come.
43:02Even though many of the individuals I've discussed have had their reputations destroyed, they'll still try crawling back to regain relevance while acting like victims. They're just like the
43:10people they hate. spineless cowards that only care about their own reputation and the reputation of their political team,
43:16not realizing that they are doing harm to that team. Last thing I want to mention here is that Ryan is actually really funny. He can take risks with his comedy and is willing to embarrass
43:24himself for it, but that alone earned my respect. It's not easy to do that and results in some pretty entertaining content. Him filming a parody of Santa
43:32May's apology is goated. Maybe this is what Nick should do for his 15th apology video. Anyways, I hope you guys have really enjoyed this video and leave
43:39suggestions below for anyone you want me to cover in the next episode of Idiot Influencers.
Chapter 9: Outro
43:45So, now I'm a very sex positive person and sex research is something that I'm very passionate about. And when he means research, he means watching his girlfriend [ __ ] other guys while he sits
43:53in the cuck chair sneaker styles taking notes.
43:58[Music]
44:12[Music]
44:15I know you
44:16[Music]
44:21know you know you I know you
44:27[Music]
44:32know you I know